Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor stopped by Sesame Street last week to have tea with her friend Maria on the children’s program 42nd season.

However, the Justice’s quiet tea time with her friend was interrupted as Baby Bear said he was having an issue.

After Justice Sotomayor explained what she does on the Supreme Court, Baby Bear asked her to hear his case against Goldilocks.

Justice Sotomayor stepped away from the table, quickly returning in a black judge’s robe saying, “I always where these robes when I hear a case.”

In the end, in the case of Goldilocks v. Baby Bear, Justice Sotomayor ruled that Goldilocks would have to repair Baby Bear’s chair, which she broke, though she did tell Baby Bear, “Goldilocks didn’t mean to break the chair, and accidents do happen.”

Watch here appearance below.